Tuesday, March 10, 2009

Payback is a bitch...

That's all I can say - we got put in our place by a damn useful Aussie side in front of our home supporters... Ouch!

Now before we do the usual South African story of throwing our hands up in the air and berating our side, we need to step back and try and put these performances into perspective.

Number 1: When we were in Australia it took heroics from Duminy, Steyn and Devilliers to ultimately keep us competitive in the first two tests which we won... We didn't walk all over the Aussies and I think that is something we need to emphasise. Both sides could have won either of the first two tests in Australia. We were less competitive at home.

Number 2: This is a good Aussie side... We mustn't forget how good this Australian side is... Johnson, Ponting, Hussey, Clarke and Katich are amongst the best in the world in respect of the positions they occupy. On top of that, Hughes looks like a world-beater in the making. Quality cricketers don't roll over and get beaten under any circumstances.

Number 3: Injuries played a part.... An injury to Graeme Smith and the knock that Kallis took invariably rattled us in our first innings. If they had been able to contribute another 100 runs in our first innings and Smith a few in the second innings the series would be all square and we would be patting ourselves on the back for chasing a mammoth total.

We didn't win it and we have to get over it. Imraan Khan and Ashwell Prince have been moved in for the injured Smith and the out-of-form Mckenzie which makes some sense and Wayne Parnell has been added to the squad in place of Morne Morkel...

... and this is where I get irritated with selection in SA cricket. Where the hell is the consistency in moving players in and out.

Bowlers: First test match Lonwabo Tsotsobe is the 12th man and I as a fan believe he will be the replacement bowler if somebody moves out. The second test match, he gets drafted out and Albie Morkel moves to the bench. Third test match, MORNE Morkel gets dropped and Parnell moves into the lineup.... Who the hell is the next choice bowler?!

Personally I think that Tsotsobe or Parnell should be at the top of the line because they offer some variety with left-arm seam where as Albie Morkel (while offering something with the batting front) offers just straight-up right arm seam. Dunno...

Batters:
I think it is great that Khan got a hundred against the Aussies in the warm-up game and he has been the top domestic run getter so he deserves a chance to play. My question is - where was he in Australia or the T20's or the ODI games?

Suddenly the guy has been drafted in to the setup... where is the succession planning. As far as I knew the next two batters in line for international spots (based on selector behaviour) were Herschelle Gibbs and Vaughn Van Jaarsveld with Andrew Puttick on the fringes... Suddenly they are pulling in Khan....

In the same way I see that Ashwell Prince is supposedly going to open the innings. This doesn't make sense and we seem to be carrying on with this idea of "making" openers out of middle-order batters.... Dunno - no consistency.

Let's see how it goes

4 comments:

Ian said...

Typical logic of South African selectors.
I don't see the move as all that bad, but I just find it a kick in the teeth for the overall team. The way they were dubbed 'wizards of Oz' or some crap, and now they axe two players and the reserve players keep chopping and changing it's hard to see what's the plan!

I see your frustration as it felt the same with my feelings towards Cricket Australia's NSP, but when they dropped favouritism and showed faith in the young guys and balanced their resources it made things work. It is a common move of South African sports to hold a guy up high, and as soon as he has one inconsistent series he gets the middle finger and is off. Just hope Dale Steyn doesn't receive that sort of treatment!
A series loss does this when a side is boosted up etc. but I have no sympathy cause the big mouths don't know when to stop and this was inevitable in my opinion.

Imraan Kahn is not a bad choice. Steve Waugh said if a guy is performing and has consistency and belief in their natural game they should be given the chance.
But you look as Aus' circumstances, the changes were for different reasons , where as SA is just another story all together. Just see how it plays out for the 3rd Test on your teams behalf.

Anonymous said...

;-)

I don't mind who the hell they pick - I just wish there would be some consistency...

I moaned about it before we went to Aus as well... Rory Kleinveldt and Johan Louw got regular games for the T20 series against Bangladesh and Kenya and next thing we know Parnell and Tsotsobe are off to Australia as the backup bowlers... would have been nice for them to cut their teeth in some slightly easier fixtures.

Ian said...

Hey Marc

I got a new site up mate:
http://www.cricscene.blogspot.com

Check it out and pop it in your blogroll if you can!
Thanks dude!

Anonymous said...

Adding it now